Initiative is going to be the first target of my tinkering. (After thief hit dice of course). For those not in the know, Holmesian initiative is a straight-up comparison of Dexterity scores of the combatants. This means that Holmian initiative is individual--not team--based. And, once established, the order remains fixed: no re-rolling each round since there's no rolling to begin with. And it also means that if you have a high dexterity you are likely to get in the first blow every time. And, probability being what it is, there are going to be a lot of folks tied-up around the 9-12 range.
But what it also means is that you're going to have to roll up a dex score for every orc, kobold, and displacer beast that decides to take on the party. And then you'll have to track each one of your uniquely dextertied critters throughout the combats.
That, for me, is a deal breaker in itself. But there's still one more nail in the coffin: the implied assumption that the 3-18 ability range that we use for humans and their ilk would be applied universally for all creatures from purple worms to pixies, zombies to giant ants. [Actually, maybe not zombies; isn't their a rule that they always lose initiative? Or is that in AD&D?] Who ever heard of a cat with a 7 dexterity? Impossible right?
I want a score that:
- Reflects all the various things that go into making you quick on the draw; things like your size and your general quickness, and, most importantly
- It has to already exist in the rules; I don't wanna be making up new statistics here. You figured this out yet?
*Hence yesterday's post, in case you were wondering what brought that on. No idea how tall that Tiritelli dude is.
So your move in olde school "inches" will be the baseline. Actually, Holmesian basic lists movement in feet, e.g. elves move 120', dwarves = 60', etc. Just drop the trailing zero for the same result. You're going to get an awful lot of ties though, since every dude in chainmail and every orc are going to have the same initiative value. So we're going to add a couple of variable to the mix: your dex adjustment (In Holmes it's +1 for dex of 13 or greater, -1 for 8 or less, I believe) and a randomizer, also known as a roll of the dice. But, in keeping with the Holmesian method, you don't re-roll every round; just once until the combat comes to a meaningful ending.
The Holmesy-Dice Chucker Initiative Formula:
Initiative = Movement + Dex adjustment + d4/d6/d8 based on hit dice
Yes, the initiative die rolled is dependent on your hit dice; MUs roll 4-siders, fighters roll d8, thieves and clerics d6 (thieves only get d4 in Basic D&D,you say? Then you haven't been paying attention). In fact, I'm thinking of extending HD to also include damage rolls: fighters would do d8 damage with whatever they use as a weapon, thieves (and clerics I suppose) do d6, and MUs will always plop down the pathetic pyramid for combat results.
Anyway, this puts encumbered folks at a serious disadvantage, which I'm ok with. At least this is a matter of players deciding how to allocate resources rather than a result of a single die roll made during k-jen that will haunt/bless your character for the rest of eternity... or until they die on the 2nd level of Skull Mountain.