Thursday, November 19, 2026

How to Read the AD&D Rules Part XVII: Roll Initiative!

On page 104 of the PHB Lord Gary has this to say under the heading "Initiative": 

"Initiative allows one group ...to begin some course of action prior to the other group." 

Actually, he says a whole lot of other stuff too, but this is the most meaningful collection of words presented within close enough proximity to each other to use as a quote. He also says in the most verbose manner conceivable that each side rolls a d6, whoever rolls higher gets to take action first. Dexterity is explicitly excluded from the initiative equation--much to the consternation of everyone who played any version of basic D&D before stepping up to the Advanced variety. 

No mention is made of of any other factors that might be involved in determining who does what when during the minute long melee round. Instead, you have to keep reading to find that shit out. Hold on Cuz on page 105 we have this: 

First Strike: 

"When important single combats occur, then dexterities and weapon factors will be used to determine the order and number of strikes in a round." 

There you have it, Dex and "weapon factors" come into play when important single combats occur. Got it.

Obviously this explanation fails to shed even a dim flicker of light on the topic so we have to turn to the DMG to see if anything useful can be made of it. On pg 62 Egg spends three even-longer paragraphs repeating himself except using even more words this time. What's the opposite of paraphrasing? 

But as with surprise, if you keep reading on you will find some very important initiative related business on the following pages. That no dex bonus thing for instance; in the Missile Discharge section, you'll find that Dex not modifying initiative only applies to everyone not attacking with missile weapons, cuz if you're hucking a spear or slinging a stone at the opposition, you can add your reaction attack modifier to the die roll on an individual basis. So the PCs roll a 3, the orcs roll a 4. Theadara the Thief launches her sling with 17 Dx, she gets to add +2 to the party's initiative roll getting a 5; she slings before the orcs. Meanwhile, her colleague Dwildor the Dwarf which is tossing its warhammer with a Dx of 12--no modifier--keeps the 3 and hurls after the orcs attack, assuming they survive Theadara's slingstone assault. 

While rolling for initiative is obviously a significant part of the ol' game, because of the whole segment system--each round is divided into 10 segments--when your actions take place depends on how far you have to move to get into position, how long it takes to load your missile-firing device, the casting time of your spell, and possibly some other factors that I can't think of at the moment. If you Charge into combat, first strike goes to whoever has the longest weapon--keeping in mind that anyone who travels more than 10' to engage in melee is technically Charging.

Weapon Speed factor: 

This doesn't come up in the regular initiative discussion, but in its own paragraph on the next page. and it's fucking diabolical.Weapon Speed Factor only comes into play if the initiative roll results in a tie. In that case, pray that you are holding a dagger in your hand, because in a tie situation, you get multiple attacks against anyone holding a weapon with a speed factor more than twice that of your weapon, as well as a third attack at the same time if your opponent is wielding an exceptionally cumbersome pole weapon. Which means that if you're a dagger wielder who wins initiative against a dude wielding a two-hander, you swing once before your opponent, if  you lose initiative you swing once after your opponent, but if you and your opponent have the same result, you attack 3 friggin' times! Pretty obvious that this was not play-tested before it showed up in the rules. We eventually worked speed factors into our game back in the 80s,  but it was pretty convoluted and we ending up dropping it after a few sessions. 

Weapon speed factor crops up again under spellcasting in melee. Here we find out two things that Gary didn't bother to mention when he was discussing initiative a couple pages back: 

  1. the die roll indicates the segment during which your opponent gets to attack. I never knew this until right now. Actually, I think I read about this on someone's blog before, but assumed it was a house rule. 
  2. The other thing that you learn here is that your weapon speed factor indicates how many segments it takes to put your weapon to use. 

Weapon speed factor comes up again under melee attacks against spellcasters:

If you attack a spellcaster in the act of casting its spell, you subtract the losing initiative die roll from the weapon speed factor of the melee attacker. If this number is lower than the casting time of the spell in segments, then the weapon attack happens before the spell goes off and will be spoiled if the strike succeeds. But this is where it all goes weird: If subtracting the die roll from the weapon speed factor results in a negative number, you take the positive value of that number (-3 becomes +3, etc), so your dagger (speed factor 2) may strike before the spell goes off if the daggerer rolled a 1 or 2--and lost the initiative--but attacking after the spellcaster if the loser rolled a 4 or 5--even if the dagger attacker won the initiative roll! This is some S-tier Gygaxian horseshit. 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment